Responsive Caregiving, Home Learning Materials, and Subsequent Language Development in Rural Pakistan and India: A Secondary Analysis

Authors

  • Ruqia Safdar Bajwa Ph.D. Assistant Professor, Department of Applied Psychology, Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan Author
  • Asia Zulfqar Ph.D. Associate Professor, Department of Education, Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan Author
  • Tehmina Sattar Ph.D. Assistant Professor, Department of Sociology, Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan, Pakistan Author
  • Fatima Tul Zahra MBA in Health and Social Care, Anglia Ruskin University, London, United Kingdom Author
  • Muhammad Imdad Ullah Ph.D. Assistant Professor, Institute of Banking and Finance, Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan, Pakistan Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.71317/kjard.2.11.2026.1076

Keywords:

Responsive caregiving, Home learning materials, Language development, Early childhood, Pakistan, India, SPRING

Abstract

Nurturing care is associated with both responsive care and access to learning materials, but the independent and combined associations of these variables with subsequent language development remain poorly understood in rural South Asian contexts. We analyzed linked 12- and 18-month assessment data from the SPRING cluster-randomized trials in Rawalpindi District, Pakistan (n = 915) and Rewari District, India (n = 1,272) using an observational secondary analysis. We assessed caregiver responsivity (11 items) and learning materials (9 items) using the HOME inventory at about 12 months, and measured Bayley-III language composite scores at about 18 months. Country-specific regressions adjusted for maternal and child characteristics and trial assignment, using CR2 small-sample cluster-robust standard errors. Four major tests were evaluated with the Holm correction. In Pakistan, learning materials were positively associated with subsequent language scores (B = 0.334, 95% CI [0.011, 0.657]), but the association was not statistically significant after Holm correction (adjusted p = .087). In India, later language scores were determined by learning materials, whereas responsivity was not (B = 0.329; p = .267). No statistically significant interaction emerged between caregiver responsivity and learning materials in either setting (p > .32). Exploratory comparisons did not identify statistically significant differences in the associations between countries. The findings suggested distinct patterns of association between the two home-environment dimensions and subsequent language development, although evidence for these associations varied across settings. The results did not support compensatory or complementary interactions. Given the observational nature of the analysis, we cannot draw causal conclusions.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-19

How to Cite

Ruqia Safdar Bajwa, Asia Zulfqar, Tehmina Sattar, Fatima Tul Zahra, & Muhammad Imdad Ullah. (2026). Responsive Caregiving, Home Learning Materials, and Subsequent Language Development in Rural Pakistan and India: A Secondary Analysis. Kashmir Journal of Academic Research and Development, 2(11), 311-319. https://doi.org/10.71317/kjard.2.11.2026.1076